Gumbo is much denser than a simple soup; the broth has a thick, almost viscous consistency. And that characteristic is most commonly created by making a roux, cooking flour and oil together until they thicken and darken. Otherwise, gumbo can be thickened with file, which is just powdered dried sassafras leaves.

What should the consistency of gumbo roux be?

Your goal is to have it a smooth and silky consistency, not lumpy. If your goal is to have Cajun type gumbo, you will want your roux to be a darker reddish brown color. In order to achieve this, turn the heat down to low. This will allow you to control the color of without burning it.

How do I thicken up my gumbo?

Thickening Your Gumbo Add a few ounces of roux at a time and cook for a few minutes before adding more. Make sure you stir in between and check for your desired consistency. Make sure your sauce doesn’t stick to the bottom of the pot.

What do you do if your gumbo is too thin?

If the gumbo is too thin, keep simmering until it is thick! In a total pinch, you can ladle out extra broth (try to avoid chunks of protein), make another roux to thicken the extra broth, and then add the thickened mixture back into the original gumbo.

Should gumbo simmer covered or uncovered?

Cooking it more slowly over medium heat will take 20-30 minutes. Add the onions, celery, and bell peppers and cook, stirring, until wilted, 4 to 5 minutes. … Reduce the heat to medium-low and cook, uncovered and stirring occasionally, for 1 hour.

How do you make gumbo darker?

Thickening. The darker the roux gets, the less thick it gets. An oil based roux will get you to that chocolate brown color. I like to use oil for my gumbo roux because oil has a higher smoke point so you can get it darker.

Is gumbo roux supposed to be thick?

“Often times people do not make the roux thick enough and it will result in a gumbo that is more like a soup than a stew,” says Dickensauge. You want to add enough flour to your fat until the roux is like a paste.

Why is my gumbo roux not thickening?

It’s important to understand, however, that as a roux colors, it loses its ability to thicken because the starch in the flour is broken down by the heat. You’ll need more brown roux than blond roux to thicken the same amount of liquid. A truly dark roux won’t thicken at all.

Does gumbo file thicken gumbo?

File’ makes the gumbo thick if you let it set for awhile. Don’t add file’ to the gumbo during cooking or else it will make the gumbo thick and stringy. You can add a pinch to the pot at the very end of cooking to thicken the gumbo – but don’t add too much or or add it too early while the gumbo is still boiling.

Do you put tomato in gumbo?

Creole gumbos most often include tomatoes, shellfish and dark roux and often okra and filé powder, an herb made from ground leaves of sassafras trees. Cajun gumbo doesn’t have tomatoes and usually also contains chicken. It’s not uncommon for both Creole and Cajun gumbo to include meats such as ham or sausage as well.

Article first time published on

Does okra thicken gumbo?

For many, OKRA, that spiny and slimy pod, is the only way to thicken a gumbo. Okra not only thickens a gumbo; it adds flavor. It is usually sliced and then sautéed with what many consider the holy trinity of gumbo-making: onions, celery and bell peppers. Okra gumbo has a subtler flavor than filé- or roux-based gumbos.

How do you thicken gumbo without okra?

To replace okra as a thickening agent in gumbo, soups, and stews, the best options are gumbo filé, roux, xanthan gum, corn starch, or nopales. Vegetables such as zucchini, green beans, and eggplant have a similar flavor and can replace okra as a side dish.

Should gumbo be served over rice?

Gumbo is traditionally served over steamed white rice (and sometimes potato salad!), with sliced scallions and hot sauce on the side. But there’s another important finishing touch: Filé (“FEE-lay”) powder, which is made from sassafras leaves. It is typically sprinkled on individual servings to thicken and season gumbo.

Why is my gumbo oily?

Cooking gumbo usually includes making a homemade stock and using a certain amount of fat, which adds tons of flavor. That same fat can end up in an oil slick at the top of the pot, leaving your gumbo with an unappetizing greasiness.

Can you add more roux to gumbo?

The roux gets you only so far. Yes, you could increase the quantity of roux even more to thicken the gumbo further, but the toasted flavor and fat can really start to weigh the gumbo down if you get too roux-heavy.

How do you know if gumbo has gone bad?

It sounds more like the recipe calls for cooking the gumbo to a point of “doneness”, and then turning down the heat so that it stays below the boiling point. In other words, if the fully cooked gumbo continues cooking at a full boil, the recipe will be spoiled.

What if my roux is too thick?

Whisk the flour into the fat until you have a smooth, thick sauce. If it’s too thick to whisk, add a little more fat. If it’s too thin, add more flour.

What color should roux be for gumbo?

A Gumbo Roux is always dark brown in color which resembles a chocolate color. This dark brown roux will make you the best Gumbo ever.

What color should gumbo be?

The heat from the stove is what helps turn a roux that deep, chocolate brown color typical of a gumbo roux. If your roux isn’t to your desired color yet, simply crank up the heat a little bit and give it some more time.

Why is my gumbo roux not getting dark?

You’re Cooking It Too Much or Too Little A blond roux is one where the roux is just barely browned. … If you keep cooking the roux, it’ll turn into a brown, peanut butter color, which is great for lighter gumbos and many sauces and stews.

How do you darken gumbo roux?

Get the oil nice and hot before adding the first bit of flour. Then, turn the heat to low, and continue adding flour, a little at a time, while you whisk. Keep whisking and adding, whisking and adding, and watch as your roux goes from white to a light peanut butter color and finally to a dark, nutty brown.

What oil is best for roux?

Richard writes, “I use butter for blond roux and for anything darker I would use peanut oil, lard, vegetable oil, canola oil in that order of preference. Most fats work, but I never use olive oil as it gives a distinct unpleasant flavor to the roux.”

What does filé powder do for gumbo?

More Information. Gumbo filé powder is the essential flavoring and thickening ingredient of gumbo and can also be used to perk up sauces and gravies. Gumbo filé is generally added after the dish has been removed from the heat, but before it cools as it becomes stringy when cooked.

Is filé powder illegal?

Its roots and bark were traditionally used to make tea and the leaves when dried and powdered are called “filé” and are most famously used in gumbo. … To be clear, the leaves of the sassafras tree do not contain enough safrole to be banned, so filé powder is fine for consumption and sale.

Do you need filé powder for gumbo?

Filé powder is almost as important in a gumbo symbolically as it is for its thickening or flavoring aspects, because of what it represents. Gumbo is the melting pot, the symbolic dish of American history, and is mostly a mixture of West African, Spanish, and French cuisines.

How do you know when a roux is done?

You’ll know the roux is ready when it turns brown and smells of roasted peanuts, about 12 to 15 minutes. A white roux forms the base of the creamy sauce that gives this baked broccoli gratin dish its signature smooth texture.

How do you make a roux thicker?

1 Tbsp. flour mixed with 1 Tbsp. of butter or other fat should yield enough roux to thicken 3/4 to 1 cup of warm liquid. To avoid lumps forming, slowing whisk liquid into the roux and simmer until mixture thickens.

What causes roux separation?

The stock has to be hot enough for the flour to mix. The oil opened the flour using heat. If the stock isn’t hot enough, the heated, open flour will cool and close on impact with the stock causing it to “separate”. Once this happens, the roux is toast.

How do you add flavor to gumbo?

1. Grill meats or roast garlic on the grill before adding to the pot for a good rustic flavor.
2. When using wild meats cut the game taste with beer or white wine.
3. Add crawfish tails or oysters.
4. Add crabmeat if you don’t want to peel the crabs.
5. Food process veggies to hide them in the gumbo.

Why is gumbo called gumbo?

Gumbo is derived from the word “gombo,” which translates to “okra” in many West African languages. The earliest recorded recipes for the dish include okra as a main ingredient, not necessarily as an afterthought or add-in by a cook who is being inventive or cleaning out their refrigerator.

Whats the difference between Creole and Cajun?

In present Louisiana, Creole generally means a person or people of mixed colonial French, African American and Native American ancestry. … “Cajun” is derived from “Acadian” which are the people the modern day Cajuns descend from.